Come Closer or Run Away

by | Nov 3, 2025 | Uncategorized

Warning: I’m feeling old & cranky, and I know that the people who need to read & understand this won’t, so that’s annoying.  But hey, it’s my blog post so I’m saying it anyway.  

I have been pondering the mess we have made of the language we use to describe learning and training; particularly in the dog professional universe. On the one hand what we say matters. Being clear and precise matters.  On the other hand, it’s very easy to end up in the weeds thrashing out picayune details. As a psychology professor specializing in learning & behavior, and professional dog trainer for 30 years, I think I have a better handle on this topic than most.  So consider class in session!

Free Back To School Classroom illustration and picture

Lately online I’ve been seeing lots of trainers who claim to be absolute keepers of truth when it comes to understanding the basics of learning theory.  Hint: they’re not.  I find myself getting very annoyed with people who attempt to twist words & phrases to mean whatever the heck they want them to mean.  Words aren’t pretzels and you have not discovered anything new and groundbreaking.  

While I’m on a roll here another pet peeve is people who claim to have developed a BRAND NEW REVOLUTIONARY concept or idea, only to find it is a fancy repackaged version of the basics of learning.  I’m always open to learning from people who have a new insight or different perspective.  But don’t intentionally mislead me. That just wastes my time and pisses me off.

Free New Brand New illustration and pictureI’m really sick and tired of hearing the same old arguments about the meanings and details surrounding positive & negative reinforcement and positive & negative punishment.  It’s been decades and, while we can understand what they mean, it’s much more complex & nuanced when it comes to understanding how they actually work in the real world.  Thinking that you’re clever because you can logic your way to saying that positive reinforcement isn’t always pleasant isn’t the mental flex you think it is.  

I do agree that the terminology around learning theory can be confusing.  In order to simplify & clarify it I think of it for my own training in a slightly different way.  Something can be considered appetitive if it’s something your trainee desires and will move towards to obtain (come closer to something that’s reinforcing).  Something can be considered aversive if it’s something your trainee would make an effort to avoid (move away from something that’s unpleasant).  Don’t take these descriptions totally literally, but as more of a theoretical model.  These terms are actually used to discuss & describe classical conditioning, but I like how they work for me in the operant world as well.  As much as realistically possible I want my training to be appetitive and not aversive.  Using this general concept to guide my training choices makes it pretty easy and straightforward to stay on the side of training that I prefer.  Does my dog want to stay in the training game with me or get away from it?  If they want to escape then I’m doing something very wrong.  

Something I see a lot of lately in the world in general, as well as the dog training world, is purposeful misunderstanding.  The purpose is to find a way to pick apart someone else’s views or statements.  It’s listening for criticism, not for understanding.  I’m very guilty of this and I blame all my years as a professor for going to critique first.  However, it’s something I’m aware that I’m doing, so that’s more than half the battle.  I don’t use it as a way to defend my position or beliefs and ignore inconvenient truths, and to me that’s a huge difference.  I use it to measure the strength of the person’s statements and determine whether there’s something there worth listening to.

I LOVE the science of learning.  I LOVE new ideas & concepts.  I LOVE training discussions with smart savvy people.  What I despise is when people try to take terms & concepts, twist them for their own purposes, and use them to try to establish intellectual superiority over others (and often sell them something as well).  That’s dishonest & manipulative.The purpose of terminology is to have a shared understanding of language.  When that’s not the case then it’s useless at best; problematic at worst.  

Deborah Jones, Ph.D. is a retired psychology professor who now trains animals full-time.  She has been training for 30+ years and focuses on positive reinforcement based methods.  Deb has written 13 books on dog training and has helped develop several DVD series way back in the day.  She has also trained and shown multiple breeds to high level titles in agility, rally, and obedience.  She is currently teaching online training classes, workshops, and webinars at www.fenzidogsportsacademy.com.  Her latest project is the Cooperative Care Trainer Certificate course.  Visit her website at www.k9infocus.com for her blog and more information.  

 

  

 

Subscribe To Our Blog by Email!

While I always have a LOT to say about dogs, training, and all sorts of related topics, one of my special interests is cooperative care work.  The ability to make physical care easier and less stressful for our dogs is an important issue for me.  There is so much we can do to make vet care and grooming a more comfortable process!  

By filling out the form below you will receive an email with a link to my Prep for the Vet ebook.  It covers all the basic information to start you down the right path.  You’ll also get emails with my blog posts as well.  

0 Comments

Earn Your Cooperative Care Trainer Certificate (CARE-TC)

Deb Jones, PhD literally wrote the book to cooperative care… and now she’s created a certificate program to help more people find a kind and gentle approach when providing physical care for dogs.

The CARE-TC is helpful for dedicated pet owners, professional trainers, veterinary professionals, and groomers.

Subscribe To Our Blog by Email!

While I always have a LOT to say about dogs, training, and all sorts of related topics, one of my special interests is cooperative care work.  The ability to make physical care easier and less stressful for our dogs is an important issue for me.  There is so much we can do to make vet care and grooming a more comfortable process!  

By filling out the form below you will receive an email with a link to my Prep for the Vet ebook.  It covers all the basic information to start you down the right path.  You’ll also get emails with my blog posts as well.  

Come Join Us!

Join the Cooperative Care Facebook Group and dive into conversations on every aspect of cooperative care!

Deb teaches Cooperative Care at Fenzi Dog Sports Academy as a regular instructor.

Visit Fenzi Dog Sports Academy